[spoilers] Episode 8 summary

[Forever Secret]

(08-11-2010 03:04 PM)A Cousin Wrote:  Good thought, harrbd. I saw the lapse in continuity as well.

Series 9.8 Spoiler: show

I am not so convinced that Ruth would have to be alive for Harry to meet with Lucas. I think it entirely possible that he would be as likely to offer his life up so quickly if she were dead. In addition, Harry's inherent sense of decency and integrity would prompt him to try to save Lucas/John in honor of Ruth.

At any rate, it is very clear that this clip is the culmination of a series dedicated to the choices they make and how the job can dehumanize them. Harry is offering Lucas a very simple choice between good and evil.

And was that a bit of the Yorkie coming through in PF's speech when he turns his back to Lucas? Love. It!

I have to concentrate on these technical things otherwise I am going to throw up!

Series 9.8 Spoiler: show

It depends, I agree at any cost he'd want to save Lucas, but Harry could offering his own life in that scene to stop Lucas hurting Ruth. If Ruth was dead by that point I would think either one of two things, Harry keeps his composure and tries to help Lucas in honour of Ruth, or he'd be so angry he'd have Lucas captured and taken and then put back in prison...
or it could be that Ruth is dead and Harry see's no reason to live, I think if Ruth died Harry would most likely retire
I agree it is a simple choice to Lucas but also a hard one, he can kill Harry, but why would he, he'd never get Albany it would achieve nothing and he'd be a murderer, killing someone he trusted and was friends with,
I think Lucas just wants to be someone, because he's forgotten who he is, he wants to be good, but can't let go of all the wrong he's done, I really want Lucas to be a good guy, maybe in the end no one will die, but he will just leave,

Ohh this wait it killing me here!

Never trust a news paper that spells names wrong