Series 9 Rumours & Speculation

[Kirayuki]

What i think...

Another way of seeing it is that maybe Malcom was given both the real one and a false one and was told to give the false one to anyne who came looking for it. (So that Harry would know someone was looking for it possibly?) Or maybe he doesn't have the real one at all and the trail would always lead to the false one if someone searched it out.
Maybe Lucas wasn't one of the three names but he said that to re-assure Lucas it was the real deal, giving him enough time to scarper.

There are so many possibilities...